IBE home page>doing business ethically ... makes for better business
publications

Publications
Summaries
Order Form

Where did that come from? a study of ethical issues in the supply chain


by Rosey Hurst & Mary Arnesen, Impactt Limited

SOLD OUT! New updated publication on this subject: Taking the Temperature

Executive Summary

1. Ethical supply chain management is becoming a mainstream business issue. Companies are being prompted to act by a variety of factors, including media and Non-Government Organisation (NGO) campaigns, changing stakeholder expectations, increasing awareness among companies of factory conditions, the threat of legal action and the desire to protect their reputation.

2. Key worker welfare issues include forced labour, freedom of association, health and safety, child labour, wages and working hours and discrimination. Agreed standards are beginning to emerge in most of these areas, although controversy remains, particularly on how to deliver standards of freedom of association and a living wage. International labour conventions and national laws govern most of these areas. However, implementation of laws and conventions is weak in most developing countries, and there are also abuses in the developed world.

3. Various methods are emerging as best practice from the experiences of pioneering companies and organisations tackling these issues.

3.1. Codes of conduct specify the company's policy on worker welfare issues in the supply chain. They demonstrate that the company is aware of the issues and wants to improve the situation. They can also act as a useful tool for setting priorities. The Ethical Trading Initiative's base code is one emerging standard.

3.2. The next step for companies is to implement the standards enshrined in their codes of conduct across their supply chains. There is little consensus about how this is best done. Important tools for implementation include training, awareness raising, management systems and incentives for managers. Even leaders in the field admit that they are only just beginning to implement codes.

3.3. Companies are then able to monitor progress towards achieving standards set out in codes. This can be done using internal, external or independent resources or a combination of all three.

3.4. Trade unions and some NGOs are insisting on external verification and public reporting of findings as an integral part of the ethical trading process. However, little consensus exists about what should be verified and who should do it.

3.5. The Council on Economic Priorities Accreditation Agency (CEPAA) has launched SA 8000, an ethical trading certification scheme.

3.6. Some companies approach improving working conditions on a project-by-project basis, instead of, or as well as, attempting to implement a code of conduct across all supply chains.

3.7. A number of cross sector partnerships between groups of companies, NGOs and trade unions have emerged. These aim to develop a consensus on how to approach improving workplace conditions and deliver improvements which are sustainable.

4. There is a general perception amongst organisations and companies in the developed world that the ethical trading debate is gathering momentum. Stakeholder pressure is mounting and more companies are feeling the need to have workable policies, despite the difficulties. However, at the moment it is mainly large companies, particularly in the retail sector, which are acting. For critical mass to be reached, small and medium sized companies also need to act. It is clear that companies cannot solve the problem single-handed. There is a need for governments, international bodies and others to become involved to make real change.

Back to Top

Registered charity no. 1084014
Address: 24 Greencoat Place, London, SW1P 1BE - Tel: +44 (0)20 7798 6040 - Fax: +44 (0)20 7798 6044 - Email: info@ibe.org.uk